Derbyshire County Councillor says decision to shelve Ivanhoe Line railway plans is “extremely wrong”

By Eddie Bisknell - Local Democracy Reporter

16th Oct 2024 | Local News

The Ivanhoe Line was due to run from Coalville to Derby. Photo: CRIL
The Ivanhoe Line was due to run from Coalville to Derby. Photo: CRIL

A decision to shelve plans to reopen the Ivanhoe Line through Ashby to Derby has been dubbed "shortsighted", "disappointing" and "extremely wrong" by a leading councillor.

In a Derbyshire County Council meeting, Cllr Tony King, cabinet member for clean growth and regeneration, hit out at the cost-cutting decision from central Government to cancel plans to reopen the Ivanhoe and Barrow Hill railway lines through Derbyshire.

Rachel Reeves, chancellor, announced in July that the Restoring Your Railway scheme was scrapped, ending the ongoing plans for the Ivanhoe Line.

If the Ivanhoe plans had been rolled out it would have removed Swadlincote from being part of a notorious list of eight English towns which have a population of more than 30,000, but do not have an operational railway station and are not within five kilometres of one.

The county council last detailed the cost of the Ivanhoe Line project at £123 million to £186 million.

Local contributions were to be between £20 million to £30.3 million for Ivanhoe - with the first phase planned to link Coalville and Derby via Ashby.

Cllr Stuart Swann, Linton division, dubbed the scrapping of the scheme "shortsighted" and asked a full council meeting for an update on the plans.

Ashby Station on the Ivanhoe Line is now home to offices. Photo: Ashby Nub News

He said he had hoped the Ivanhoe scheme would have taken traffic off the congested A444 - running from Burton to Appleby Magna.

Cllr King, responding on behalf of Cllr Carolyn Renwick, cabinet member for infrastructure and environment, said: "It is deeply disappointing that both the Ivanhoe and Barrow Hill railway line projects which had previously been accepted into the Restoring Your Railways programme set up by the previous government have been shelved.

"These schemes have been promoted locally by this council, its partners, its communities and the former local MP.

"Our officers have supported the development of these projects from inception to outline business case stage, working closely with both the Department for Transport and Network Rail.

"By reaching the outline business case stage the projects were well-advanced with preliminary station designs, service patterns and expected economic benefits all being complete.

"It is therefore very shortsighted that the decision to pause the Restoring Your Railways programme has been made at the very point that both projects were seeking approval to enter the final stage of the preparation of delivery.

"Not only is it shortsighted, it is very disappointing.

"The decision now means that the communities of Barrow Hill, Killamarsh and Castle Gresley will have to wait much longer for a railway station and to have these vital connections restored, hugely impacting real economic benefits with the potential to regenerate local economies by opening access to jobs, education, supporting new housing developments and boosting tourism.

"Both projects will now be held in abeyance and will not progress to a full business case."

Cllr King said the council would hand the documents for both projects to the East Midlands Combined County Authority for consideration as part of any transport projects for the region, and said the county would continue to "lobby to overturn the decision".

He added: "The East Midlands is the bottom region for investment in transport and this is particularly true in rail.

"Anyone who uses EMR to go to London and uses local services knows how far we are behind.

"There were some flashes of light with HS2 at one time, they keep talking about the Midland Mainline electrification… I don't think I shall live to see it but maybe it will come.

"These projects are in areas where we could have really regenerated the area and would have hit far beyond their wait - and would have been an extremely valuable contribution to people's mobility and communications within the East Midlands.

"It is absolutely vital we keep the pressure on to get these projects done.

"We were 95 per cent of the way there to getting them done and then the ground is cut from under you and that, I think, is extremely wrong."

Ms Reeves said the Restoring Your Railway fund needed to be cut, saving £85 million in committed funding, to plug a £21.9 billion black hole in public finances.

The first phase of the line was planned to run from Coalville to Derby. Photo: Instantstreetview.com

Individual schemes could be assessed by Transport Secretary Louise Haigh, but for now projects yet to progress to their building stages had been halted.

In total, the Government's halting of what it called "unaffordable road and railway schemes" will save it a projected £785 million.

Ms Reeves had told Parliament: "The previous Government also made a series of commitments on transport, promises that people expected to be delivered and promises that many members across this House campaigned on in good faith, but the Conservative party has failed them. 

"We have seen from the National Audit Office the chaos that the previous Government presided over, with projects over budget and delayed again and again. 

"The spending audit has revealed £1 billion of unfunded transport projects that have been committed to next year, so my right honourable friend the Transport Secretary will undertake a thorough review of these commitments. 

"As part of that work, she has agreed not to move forwards with projects that the previous Government refused to publicly cancel, despite knowing full well that they were unaffordable."

North West Leicestershire's Labour MP, Amanda Hack, says she is currently in negotiations to get the Ivanhoe Line back on track.

     

New ashby Jobs Section Launched!!
Vacancies updated hourly!!
Click here: ashby jobs

Share:

Related Articles

Image: The National Forest Company
Local News

National Forest reports huge uptake in regular outdoor learning from primary schools across the region

North West Leicestershire MP Amanda Hack reported on her first 100 days. Photo: Supplied
Local News

Amanda Hack says future of Ivanhoe Line has been discussed in first 100 days since becoming North West Leicestershire MP

Sign-Up for our FREE Newsletter

We want to provide ashby with more and more clickbait-free local news.
To do that, we need a loyal newsletter following.
Help us survive and sign up to our FREE weekly newsletter.

Already subscribed? Thank you. Just press X or click here.
We won't pass your details on to anyone else.
By clicking the Subscribe button you agree to our Privacy Policy.